ICE CREAM FLAVORS

We create all the flavors you know and love, and make them better! At Motley Moo Creamery, we specialize in classic ice cream flavors- some true to their beloved taste and others with a unique twist. 

We feature 13 ice cream flavors in our dipping cabinet as well as 1 dairy-free/vegan option. Our flavors rotate weekly and some come and go with the seasons. Please give us a call or swing by our scoop shop to see what's currently available. See below for some of our ice cream flavors.

 

(Jump to: Constant Flavors, Rotating Flavors, or Dairy-Free Flavors)

Constant Flavors
 (you can count on these flavors always being avaliable)

Classic Vanilla
​​Some classics never go out of style! Made with wholesome dairy and real vanilla, there’s no wonder why this humble flavor is a top seller year after year. 

Chocolate
Take a trip to the Dark Side of the Moon with this flavor. Our chocolate is rich, dark & creamy with a fudge brownie taste. Made with just the right amount of sweetness & real cocoa for an out of this world treat!​ ​

Strawberry
​​​This all-time American favorite is super-smooth, super-creamy & so full of fresh strawberry flavor, with one bite your taste buds will have you thinking its summer all year long!​​

Sweet Cream
Simply the best…better than all the rest! This delicious & simple flavor highlights the wholesome dairy products we use in each batch of ice cream. 

Coffee
We usually go for a cup of coffee first thing in the morning, but we won’t judge if you grab a bowl of our coffee ice cream instead! Perfectly balanced & delicious, our coffee ice cream is great anytime of the day.

Cookies & Cream
Vanilla Ice Cream with Oreo® Cookie Pieces
Like a Double Stuffed Oreo® but better! This ice cream tastes like Oreo® cream filling & is chock-full of Oreo® cookie pieces.

 

---

Rotating Flavors
(these flavors rotate on a regular basis)

Classics

Rocky Road
Chocolate Ice Cream with Marshmallows & Almond Pieces
“Here I go again on my own…goin’ down the only road I've ever known…” If the road you're headed down is made of creamy chocolate ice cream, chewy marshmallows & crunchy almond pieces, we’ve made up our mind…we’re coming with you!​

Purple Haze
​Wild Blueberry Ice Cream with a Wild Blueberry Swirl
This ice cream gives you a double dose of wild blueberries! Wild blueberry ice cream with swirls of “Purple Haze”. Take it in and enjoy its floral, tartly sweet taste.

Butter Pecan
​Butter Pecan Ice Cream with Butter Pecan Pieces
Crunchy, salty & buttery brown sugared pecan pieces plus sweet & creamy butter pecan flavored ice cream…yes please!

Blue Moon
Making its debut in the Last Frontier, this cosmic-colored flavor is a Midwest mystery! Its blue color, sweet, slightly fruity taste takes us back to childhood memories of watching weekend cartoons while eating a bowl of Froot Loops®. This is childhood on a spoon!

Dark Cherry Chunk
​Dark Cherry Ice Cream with Bing Cherry Chunks
Cherries galore! Our dark cherry ice cream is loaded with delicious Pacific Northwest Bing cherries for that classic cherry taste.

Cookie Dough
​​Vanilla Ice Cream with Chunks of Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Gobs & gobs of LOCALLY MADE chocolate chip cookie dough! Need we say more…

Neapolitan
​Vanilla, Chocolate & Strawberry Ice Cream
Forever separated, but always touching, the flavors said to each other-”Though we’ve touched and went our separate ways…true love won't dessert you…you know I still love you, though we touched and went our separate ways.”

Chocolate Chip
​Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Dark Chocolate Flakes
Our Sweet Cream ice cream is speckled throughout with flecks of dark chocolate, giving each bite just the right amount of crunch.

Orange Twist
​​Vanilla & Orange Ice Cream 
We’re goin’ back to our elementary school days with this flavor! Remember those orange & vanilla ice cream treats that came in a plastic cup with a tiny wooden spoon? Take a trip down memory lane with a better version of your favorite childhood treat.

Chocolate Brownie Chunk
​​Chocolate Ice Cream with Brownie Chunks
Chocolate...check
LOCALLY MADE fudge brownies...check.
​Our work is done here.

Mixed Berry
Chocked full of blueberries, strawberries, raspberries, blackberries and a hint of hibiscus blossom- all swirled together in creamy, dreamy, berry deliciousness.

Cinnamon
This ice cream is loaded with cinnamon sugary goodness! Spicy cinnamon blends with sweet brown sugar for an ice cream that is warm & inviting. Great alone  or as a complement to another dessert.

Cotton Candy
If you want to feel like a kid again…you should go to the Alaska State Fair & ride the Ferris wheel, get your face painted & jump for joy when you’ve correctly fooled the guesser (OR) you could avoid the lines & eat a scoop of our cotton candy ice cream! Either option sounds like fun!

Coconut
Creamy coconut ice cream makes for a perfect island getaway. Only thing missing is the sand! 

BT Toffee
​​​Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Heath Bar® Pieces
Chunks of HEATH ® Bar are added to our sweet cream base for a creamy, crunchy, chocolaty, buttery, toffee combination of heavenly proportions. 

---

---

Classics with a Twist

Freckle-Faced Mint
​Peppermint Ice Cream with Dark Chocolate Flakes
Refreshingly cool & creamy, our peppermint ice cream is made with brown sugar & “freckled” with delicate, yet crunchy flakes of dark chocolate.

​Sweet Child of Mine
Donut Ice Cream with Natural Rainbow Sprinkles
A favorite of that Sweet Child of Mine, the inspiration for this ice cream came from a pregnancy craving that involved eating 24 donut holes in a matter of minutes! Each batch is proudly made with fresh LOCAL donuts & natural rainbow sprinkles.

Are you Half-Baked or Not?
​​Sweet Cream Ice Cream with Chunks of LOCAL Chocolate Chip Cookies & Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
You don’t have to choose between chocolate chip cookie dough or baked chocolate chip cookies in your ice cream. We’ve done the decision making for you, so enjoy the best of both worlds. How you choose to answer the above question is entirely up to you!

Crude Oil
Chocolate Ice Cream with a Salted Fudge Swirl
Our house made salted fudge resembles the black viscous crude oil flowing through the Trans Alaska Pipeline System (TAPS). Combined with our decadent, dark & creamy chocolate ice cream; this combination is so rich in chocolate flavor, we should have named it “black gold”.

Pink Bubble Gum
​​Bubble Gum Ice Cream with Marshmallow Pieces
This is our twist on pink bubble gum ice cream. We’ve recreated this classic flavor with real ingredients and “bubble gum” you’re actually supposed to eat!

Stuck on You
​​Banana Ice Cream with a Toasted Soy Nut Butter Swirl
Rumor has it, Elvis was a big fan of banana & peanut butter ice cream. It so happens that we are too…minus the peanuts! This ice cream is made with perfectly riped bananas & ribbons of amazing creamy peanut & tree nut free peanut butter replacement… phew, say that 5 times!

Mamma Dat' My Jam!
​​Milk Jam (Dulce de Leche) Ice Cream
When he hears his favorite song come on the radio, he loudly exclaims- “Mamma, dat’ my jam! Turn it up!” Turn your tastebuds up to 10 with our housemade milk jam ice cream! 

Oh Sherrie Cherry
​​​​Vanilla Ice Cream with Sherry Soaked Cherries
No drama in this relationship! Our love for macerated cherries will serenade your taste buds with their ability to hold on…hold on to “Sherrie” wine! Reminiscent of cherries jubilee, we add vanilla ice cream & it’s a match made in heaven.

Cow Traxx
​​Vanilla Ice Cream with a Salted Fudge Swirl & Chopped Toasted Soy Nut Butter Cups
We start with our Classic Vanilla ice cream, swirl it with house made salted fudge & fold in chopped house made toasted soy nut butter cups. The sweet side of salty is “udderly” delicious!

Midnight Train
​Chocolate Ice Cream with Milk Jam Swirls and LOCAL Dark Chocolate covered White Chocolate & Vanilla Truffles Pieces
You can take the Midnight Train goin’ anywhere, but may we suggest chocolate lover’s paradise? Take one bite of this flavor & your Journey will be underway.

Jim, Johnnie & Jack
​​​Vanilla & Whiskey Ice Cream
For this ice cream, we caught up to our pal Jack Daniels® & his partner Jim Beam®. Then we ran into Johnnie Walker® & his brother Vanilla Bean. Go ahead…indulge alone, with nobody else…‘cause we know when you eat ice cream alone, you prefer to be by yourself. 

Whole Latte Love
​​Coffee & Vanilla Ice Cream
You’ll have a Whole Latte Love for the taste of this ice cream. We add coffee and vanilla flavors to our sweet cream base for a frozen form of your favorite coffee drink.

Mocha Almond Fudge
​Mocha Ice Cream with a Salted Fudge Swirl & Almond Pieces
Coffee and Chocolate have always been a winning combination. Swirl in some house made Salted Fudge and roasted almonds and that winning combination just keeps gettin’ better!

Bohemian Raspberry
​​​Black Raspberry Ice Cream with Milk Chocolate Chunks
We can already hear your taste buds singing…“(Galileo) Galileo, Galileo Figaro. Magnifico-o-o-o-o!” Go on…keep singing!

Malted Moo & Cookies
​​Malted Sweet Cream Ice Cream & LOCAL Chocolate Chip Cookie Pieces
Milk and cookies! We take this classic combination to a new level with a malted sweet cream base and LOCALLY MADE chocolate chip cookies.

Tutti Frutti Crunch
​Toasted Marshmallow Ice Cream with Fruity Pebbles® Rice Krispie Treat Pieces
Toasted Marshmallow ice cream mixed with chunks of Fruity Pebbles® Rice Krispie Treats…a-bop-bop-a-loom-op a-lop bop boom!

Wild Honey
​​​Honey Whiskey Ice Cream with Wild Flower Honeycomb Pieces
Got a taste of wild honey …this flavors’ got the sweetness of a honey bee…wild flower honey… but will sting you good, yes sirree with a nip of Honey Whiskey.

Banana Chip
​​Banana Ice Cream with Dark Chocolate Flakes
It’s a deconstructed chocolate covered banana! Banana ice cream speckled throughout with delicate flecks of dark chocolate…such a delicious combination you’ll want more than one scoop!

Love Bites
​Sweet Cream Ice Cream with LOCAL Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough & Brownie Pieces
Love bites…but it can’t be all that bad! Check out loves sweeter side by grabbing a scoop of this ice cream and sinking your teeth into bite sized pieces of LOCALLY MADE dark chocolate brownie and chocolate chip cookie dough.

Banana Split
​​​Strawberry, Banana & Vanilla Ice Cream with a Salted Fudge Swirl, Cherry Chunks, Cool Whip® Dollops & Almond Pieces
Enjoy a banana split in one delicious scoop! Strawberry, Banana & Classic Vanilla ice creams are swirled together with our house made salted fudge, cherry chunks, Cool Whip® dollops and almond pieces.

Cocoa-Nutty Cow
​​Coconut Ice Cream with Milk Chocolate Flakes & Almond Pieces
We've deconstructed our favorite candy bar & turned it into an ice cream worth celebrating. Coconut ice cream showered with milk chocolate flakes & almond pieces.

 

---

Dairy-Free Flavors
(cashew and coconut base)

Dairy-Free Vanilla
​Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert
It’s our Classic Vanilla ice cream reinvented! Our frozen dessert version has the same creamy, sweet taste you’d expect from our original ice cream, except its vegan & dairy-free.

Dairy-Free Chocolate
Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert
It’s our Chocolate ice cream reinvented! Our frozen dessert version has the same rich & creamy taste you’d expect from our original ice cream, except its vegan & dairy-free.

Dairy-Free Cookies & Cream
​​Vanilla Dairy-Free Frozen Dessert with Oreo® Cookie Pieces
It’s our Cookies & Cream ice cream reinvented! Our frozen dessert version is chock-full of Oreo ® cookie pieces & has the same creamy, sweet taste you’d expect from our original ice cream- only vegan & dairy-free.

Dairy-Free Freckle-Faced Mint
Non-Dairy Peppermint Frozen Dessert with Dark Chocolate Flakes
It’s our Freckle-Faced Mint ice cream reinvented! Our frozen dessert version is has the same cool, creamy & sweet taste you’d expect from our original ice cream- only vegan & dairy-free.

Dairy-Free Coffee
Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert
It’s our Coffee ice cream reinvented! Our frozen dessert version has the same rich & bold creamy taste you’d expect from our original ice cream, except its vegan & dairy-free.

Dairy-Free Salted Caramel
Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert
It’s our Salted Caramel ice cream reinvented! Our frozen dessert version has the same salty sweet taste you’d expect from our original ice cream, except its vegan & dairy-free. 

Dairy-Free Strawberry
Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert
It’s our Strawberry ice cream reinvented! Our frozen dessert version has the same sweet creamy taste you’d expect from our original ice cream, except its vegan & dairy-free.

Dairy-Free Wild Blueberry
Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert
It’s our Wild Blueberry ice cream reinvented! Our frozen dessert version has the same tartly sweet taste you’d expect from our original ice cream, except its vegan & dairy-free.

Dairy-Free Coconut
Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert
It’s our Coconut ice cream reinvented! Our frozen dessert version has the same creamy & tropical taste you’d expect from our original ice cream, except its vegan & dairy-free.